A War of Whispers Review | Board Game | Zatu Games UK

    Zed has hand-picked an exciting and varied selection of games in his subscription box. Expect to receive some of the best games as well as a few surprises!

    Subscribe Now »

    Looking for the latest new releases? Then this is the subscription for you, each month you’ll receive a mystery box full of the newest and biggest games!

    Subscribe Now »

    Our two new Mystery Box offerings will help you pick up some of the latest top of the range games and exclusive goodies, but at a much lower price!

    Order Now »

    Menu

    Buy 3, get 3% off - use code BOARD3 · Buy 5, get 5% off - use code BOARD5

    Buy The Game

    Awards

    85%

    Rating

    • Artwork
    • Complexity
    • Replayability
    • Player Interaction
    • Component Quality

    You Might Like

    • Quick to learn
    • Engaging interactions between players
    • Plays in an hour
    • Quite unique in the area control genre

    Might Not Like

    • Components and artwork
    • Questions over long term replay value

    Have you tried?

    Find out more about our blog & how to become a member of the blogging team by clicking here

    A War of Whispers Review

    When UK board game reviewers Shut Up & Sit Down review a game positively you know it is going to sell out quickly. Thankfully I was able to snag a copy of Starling Games latest A War of Whispers. Attempting to flip the standard 'dudes on a map' on its head, Whispers doesn't cast you as an army. Instead you play a secretive, shady organisation of behind the scenes meddlers. Does it work? Read on!

    A War of Whispers

    Whispers is set in a fictional universe where five empires are competing for dominance of the known world. For ease of use these all come in their own colours and with their own favourite animals. Green are technically Elephants but I always call them 'Tuskys' and the horse themed browns I call 'Donks'. Regardless these colours and animals are merely visual assistance to quickly tell what is going on.

    Which makes it all the more puzzling why the rest of the game is a little bland. Don't get me, wrong the art isn't bad per se, it's just washed out and muted. This doesn't make a difference on the cards, but on the board it can be hard to locate the three important features. Those are cities, towers and farms. Farms are particularly bad as they are represented by tiny muddy haystacks, which are hard enough to see without up to six cubes clogging things up.

    A War of Graphical Design Choices

    Speaking of which, let's take a trip to the contents of the box itself. You may know Whispers started life as a Kickstarter. If you didn't know that you sure will when you open the box, and not for good reasons. The insert is awash with empty compartments that are clearly there to house the deluxe version. It's a bit of a kick in the proverbial teeth - especially when the standard components are quite poor.

    The wooden cubes themselves are fine and likely better suited to the constant moving about than the upgraded plastic flags. But the punch board is average and not cut neatly, the player boards are flimsy and there is not actually much in the box. In fact your first thought upon ripping off the shrink will probably be 'I paid how much for this?' Despite this, and some up coming gameplay worries, I still love it.

    A Gaggle(?) of Whispers

    At the start of the game you randomly place five empire tokens face down on your player mat. These are crucial to your score as they tell you which Empires will score you more points for control of cities.

    Whispers comes with a round board with the turn resolution helpfully around the edge. It works like this, each player gets 9 agent tokens, during each of the four rounds they will place two of these on to the board to influence one of the empires. In rounds 2-4 you will start by removing one of your existing agents from the board, before adding your other two one player at a time.

    Each Empire has a row of four advisors that you can use your agents to influence. Interestingly you also get to influence any of the four advisors to the left that don't have a rival players agent on. This leads to people risking an agent on the far right advisor, and then another player immediate blocking them by playing an agent one advisor left.

    A Whisper of Advisors

    Advisors will give you one or two actions to choose, including taking cards of that Empire, placing out their banners (cubes), or starting fights. Often these actions are made more powerful by an Empires control over farms or towers. Control is assigned to the Empire with cubes in a region or one of their home regions without any cubes in. Home region borders are helpfully the same colour as the Empire itself.

    Then you will move around the edge of the board activating the Empires one at a time. This means that the blue 'flappy wing' Empire will always act first and the brown 'donks' always last. Herein lies my potential worry about long term gameplay - it seems to me that browns always have the advantage. I have played the game around 8 times now and although I'm still not 100% I always think my job easier if Brown is my best scoring Empire.

    Each Empires have slightly different actions, leaning towards fights or deployment more. Also Blues have only one city in their home region but start with the most cubes on the board. Browns however have four cities but no cubes.

    A Whisper of Wars

    Despite this I find myself entranced by the game. The interplay of trying to work out what your opponents are doing works so well. The game plays in under an hour and every choice feels important. Obviously you need to bluff your opponents so they don't torpedo your favourite empires, but unless you grab an advisor in those colours early there is no guarantee you will get one at all.

    After a play or two you will understand the importance and power of the Empire cards. Each Empire has it's own deck with three powers on. Each power has a card cost, the first is the card the power is on, but the second two powers require you to discard a second card. The third most powerful action requires you to discard a card of a certain other Empire. So if you want those powers you are going to have to diversify your actions.

    Lastly at the end of every round bar the last, you may swap your loyalty between two Empires - but only if you now have those tokens face up. This gives your opponents a lot of information with which to deduce which Empires are move valuable to you.

    A Game of Two Halves

    So despite component concerns, and replay value worries Whispers is a game I love to play. It is easy to teach and everyone I have played with seems genuinely engaged and into the concept. Even the lack of visual clarity is forgiven due to the exciting and fast gameplay. Some of the best moments happen in the final scoring. You think you have done enough to win, only for the other players to reveal slightly different loyalties than what you had guessed leaving you last place.

    The game is littered with fragile alliances as you team up with one player to destroy the blues, whilst fighting with the same player for control of browns cities. While there is no encouragement of table talk in the rules, a liberal dose of deal making and back stabbing comes naturally to the game. The game is most tense when the randomly assigned loyalty is polar opposite but is still fun when you have the same loyalties as other players.

    If there does turn out to be a long term 'brown advantage' I think I'd still keep the game as it is sooooo easy to teach and play. In fact that reminds me, I need to go and find some farms, towers and cities to 3D print...

    Zatu Score

    85%

    Rating

    • Artwork
    • Complexity
    • Replayability
    • Player Interaction
    • Component Quality

    You might like

    • Quick to learn
    • Engaging interactions between players
    • Plays in an hour
    • Quite unique in the area control genre

    Might not like

    • Components and artwork
    • Questions over long term replay value

    Zatu Blog

    Find out more about our blog & how to become a member of the blogging team by clicking here

    Join us today to receive exclusive discounts, get your hands on all the new releases and much more!

    Excellent
    08000075444
    Bowthorpe Main Centre, Unit 15, Norwich NR5 9HA
    Zatu Games is rated 4.91 based on 11175
    Reviews

    very easy experience. prices seem to change daily, which makes things 'interesting' if you know what you're looking for!

    very easy experience. prices seem to change daily, which makes things 'interesting' if you know what you're looking for!

    Excellent and easy to use ordering. Shipped quickly and arrived faster than I thought it would in the US. Thanks

    Excellent and easy to use ordering. Shipped quickly and arrived faster than I thought it would in the US. Thanks

    Always enjoyable to while away some time finding new and interesting things, as well as old favourites. Excellent.

    Always enjoyable to while away some time finding new and interesting things, as well as old favourites. Excellent.

    Good prices, easy check out and have always had quick shipping.

    Good prices, easy check out and have always had quick shipping.

    Excellent range of games, really helpful product descriptions and delivered promptly

    Excellent range of games, really helpful product descriptions and delivered promptly

    Delivery was easy and on time. Love getting victory points back.

    Delivery was easy and on time. Love getting victory points back.

    Quick delivery, no issues. Thank you

    Quick delivery, no issues. Thank you

    Really good site, often best prices I can find - great selection too. Only MINOR gripe is I spent £80 though and would have been great to have free postage at that price rather than another £3 but worth it anyway.

    Really good site, often best prices I can find - great selection too. Only MINOR gripe is I spent £80 though and would have been great to have free postage at that price rather than another £3 but worth it anyway.

    Been using Zatu for several months since finding them online, rarely beaten on price and delivery always timely. No complaints at all, would highly recommend them!

    Been using Zatu for several months since finding them online, rarely beaten on price and delivery always timely. No complaints at all, would highly recommend them!

    Consistently excellent service, products & prices! The best there is & very much appreciate the efforts!

    Consistently excellent service, products & prices! The best there is & very much appreciate the efforts!

    Read All Reviews